So little faithWild to me that 3 years later people are still trying to fit a square peg into a round hole, trying to make a video switcher into a playout system when plenty of free/open source/commercial playout solutions exist, while obs's focus is being a solid video switcher & compositor. To each their own I suppose, but it's the equivalent of trying to force excel to perform as a large database, or use a motorcycle to tow a trailer. Could you use these things for this purpose? Sure, to an extent. Should you? absolutely not. Right tool, right job is the way to go, but best of luck to those still trying to hack this together still years later (and best of luck having it perform as stable and able to error correct/adjust it self to the degree proper playout systems for broadcast and similar do.)
You should encourage people to use obs in new ways. A full blown 24/7 does take a lot of work to create. I'm running beta testing on my app and it's pretty stable. It's been running and "COMPOSITING" 24/7 program schedule and streaming for 20 straight days now. Once set up, it can schedule programs months or years in advance and do it in a way that uses Fresh videos years out if desired. You may not be interested in 24/7 but there are people that are, especially if the app reduces station management to one man instead of a crew. I've studied some of the free stuff available and found it tedious to use and the better it is, the more it costs. I suggest that since you have used some of these software products, that it would be of great value that you tell us your experiences and recommendations. That would add value to the obs community.Wild to me that 3 years later people are still trying to fit a square peg into a round hole, trying to make a video switcher into a playout system when plenty of free/open source/commercial playout solutions exist, while obs's focus is being a solid video switcher & compositor. To each their own I suppose, but it's the equivalent of trying to force excel to perform as a large database, or use a motorcycle to tow a trailer. Could you use these things for this purpose? Sure, to an extent. Should you? absolutely not. Right tool, right job is the way to go, but best of luck to those still trying to hack this together still years later (and best of luck having it perform as stable and able to error correct/adjust it self to the degree proper playout systems for broadcast and similar do.)
Thanks Danny for the kind commentI personally think this will work great for Broadcasters with a very limited budget.
Can't wait for version 1.0 it looks very promising.
Please PM me with details.Thanks for reply, would be great to test it with our tv channels and good luck with the development!
Would love to see a video of your app in action or a url of your working station.dot com - big IT firm
Check my sheduler (working with version websocket 4.9.1): https://weblive.pro/scheduler_for_obs.exe
has nothing to do with 'faith' - hit a nail with a rock hard enough for long enough you'll eventually get somewhere....So little faith
I'd rather not, and instead focus more at helping someone excel at using things even better for the purposes they are designed for, whether that be a software switcher like obs, or any of the many existing playout systems for 24/7 station management. It so happens these forums are for the former, not the latter.You should encourage people to use obs in new ways.
I don't think anyone is disputing that? Another reason to use systems built for those tasks - more time executing instead of building.A full blown 24/7 does take a lot of work to create.
That's excellent, congrats!I'm running beta testing on my app and it's pretty stable.
not sure why you threw compositing in caps and quotes here?It's been running and "COMPOSITING"
I at no point ever said I wasn't interested in 24/7 and that no one was...You may not be interested in 24/7 but there are people that are,
again, that's why I've said time and again 'right tool, right job' - there are existing playout / management systems who's focus is literally 24x7 station management to create a one-man band scenario. Their sole focus and development is on that goal, not being a software video switcher being retooled for a use case it wasn't initially designed around.especially if the app reduces station management to one man instead of a crew.
I've shared those recommendations many times before. The 'value' has been added. It's far more valuable to speak to / assist with / make recommendations on the product this forum is devoted to and the use cases it's primary usage and development focus is centered on.I suggest that since you have used some of these software products, that it would be of great value that you tell us your experiences and recommendations. That would add value to the obs community.
thank you for your commentsI'd rather not, and instead focus more at helping someone excel at using things even better for the purposes they are designed for, whether that be a software switcher like obs, or any of the many existing playout systems for 24/7 station management. It so happens these forums are for the former, not the latter.
I don't think anyone is disputing that? Another reason to use systems built for those tasks - more time executing instead of building.
That's excellent, congrats!
not sure why you threw compositing in caps and quotes here?
I at no point ever said I wasn't interested in 24/7 and that no one was...
again, that's why I've said time and again 'right tool, right job' - there are existing playout / management systems who's focus is literally 24x7 station management to create a one-man band scenario. Their sole focus and development is on that goal, not being a software video switcher being retooled for a use case it wasn't initially designed around.
I've shared those recommendations many times before. The 'value' has been added. It's far more valuable to speak to / assist with / make recommendations on the product this forum is devoted to and the use cases it's primary usage and development focus is centered on.
As I said previously in the post you were quoting from, I was literally just surprised people are trying to square-peg-into-a-round-hole this solution still after 4 years of this thread (that started from people not knowing what playout systems and schedulers are or that they existed and looking for that solve), rather than use the many that have existed for years and kept everything from decent sized stations all the way down to no-budget free ones going for many years, and I wish those still trying to hammer away at this all the best.
Incredibly weird assumptions after I've now wished you luck twice in addition to very clearly stating in my last post that the old one was purely stating surprise that people were still trying to reinvent the wheel, nothing more. Maybe third time is the charm, but I wish you luck on your project...I also get the feeling you would like this thread to disappear.
... as well as your other extracurricular activities.I've looked at your other posts
thanks for your well wishesIncredibly weird assumptions after I've now wished you luck twice in addition to very clearly stating in my last post that the old one was purely stating surprise that people were still trying to reinvent the wheel, nothing more. Maybe third time is the charm, but I wish you luck on your project...
... as well as your other extracurricular activities.
Hi Gary, tell me a little more about yourself and what you are trying to do. Also how much and what kind of content do you have. it takes a lot of content to fill up a 24/7 channel? youtube, twitch,facebook? Just music, not music video?I’m trying to establish a 24/7 broadcast of my music and other content. It isn’t critical for it to be up 24/7 just yet as I’m not promoting it yet. If you need someone to alpha or beta test, I’d be happy to oblige.
The content will be repetitive. It’s intended to just be the good old-fashioned “broadcast” concept rather than “on-demand” because lots of people still gravitate towards that. I intend to be doing regular podcasts and interviews in the near future. But, while the machine isn’t being used for podcasts, I want OBS to run a continuous livestream of my music compositions and related documentary content. Once a day I would switch parts of the programming out… one song for another, one documentary for another.Hi Gary, tell me a little more about yourself and what you are trying to do. Also how much and what kind of content do you have. it takes a lot of content to fill up a 24/7 channel? youtube, twitch,facebook? Just music, not music video?