Question / Help Black screen game capture

kyomoto

New Member
I try recording an indie game with Game Capture and it's just black screen. I tried window capture but when I capture it the video comes out extremely choppy as if it was taking pictures.

I've realized after being able to record overwatch gameplay that the choppiness still persists. On the old OBS it records fine but I don't know what's wrong now.

TGBf18C.png

7Kb9jRd.png
 
Last edited:
If your game capture is black, try running OBS Studio as an administrator.

As for the choppy recording, your bitrate is way too low for recording 1080p@60fps. Either reduce your output resolution, or increase the bitrate to something like 5000-7000 Kbps. Alternatively, follow this guide on high quality recordings for OBS Studio.

Try those things and post new logs if you're still having problems.
 
Last edited:
If your game capture is black, try running OBS Studio as an administrator.

As for the choppy recording, your bitrate is way too low for recording 1080p@60fps. Either reduce your output resolution, or increase the bitrate to something like 5000-7000 Kbps. Alternatively, follow this guide on high quality recordings.

Try those things and post new logs if you're still having problems.
Administrator does nothing.

The thing is on the old OBS I'm able to do 1080 60fps ima have to check the settings to see and post a picture so that i can show you and have you compare them.
 
See, the problem is those settings are not equivalent. You're using CBR in OBS Studio and explicitly disabling it in OBS Classic. OBS Classic and OBS Studio are different pieces of software with different guides on settings.

Here is the OBS Classic recording guide.

Here is the OBS Studio recording guide.

In OBS Classic, the recommendation is to disable CBR and VBV to let the encoder choose whatever bitrate needed to adhere to your CRF setting. In OBS Studio, the recommendation (when using x264) is to just set the encoder to use CRF as the rate control method.
 
Last edited:
See, the problem is those settings are not equivalent. You're using CBR in OBS Studio and explicitly disabling it in OBS Classic. OBS Classic and OBS Studio are different pieces of software with different guides on settings.

Here is the OBS Classic recording guide.

Here is the OBS Studio recording guide.

In OBS Classic, the recommendation is to disable CBR and VBV to let the encoder choose whatever bitrate needed to adhere to your CRF setting. In OBS Studio, the recommendation (when using x264) is to just set the encoder to use CRF as the rate control method.
So what do i change in Studio to make it similar or the same? Edit: Oh I see
 
See, the problem is those settings are not equivalent. You're using CBR in OBS Studio and explicitly disabling it in OBS Classic. OBS Classic and OBS Studio are different pieces of software with different guides on settings.

Here is the OBS Classic recording guide.

Here is the OBS Studio recording guide.

In OBS Classic, the recommendation is to disable CBR and VBV to let the encoder choose whatever bitrate needed to adhere to your CRF setting. In OBS Studio, the recommendation (when using x264) is to just set the encoder to use CRF as the rate control method.
Alright so i tried to change it to CRF and put 15 with VeryFast as the cpu usage, its noticeably less choppy but nonetheless unwatchable, what should i mess with to get it steady?
 
Post a new log exhibiting the problematic behavior so we can see if there are other factors arising so we can make recommendations on what to adjust.

Also, bear in mind that Overwatch is pretty CPU intensive. On the system I use (with an i5-3570K), I use a hardware encoder rather than x264 because the two have trouble running at the same time. Your CPU benchmarks close to the one I use (some benchmarks have one slightly higher than the other, while others have them swapped). Have you checked your CPU usage to see if it's maxing out? All the same, a new log would help us verify if there are encoder issues.
 
Post a new log exhibiting the problematic behavior so we can see if there are other factors arising so we can make recommendations on what to adjust.

Also, bear in mind that Overwatch is pretty CPU intensive. On the system I use (with an i5-3570K), I use a hardware encoder rather than x264 because the two have trouble running at the same time. Your CPU benchmarks close to the one I use (some benchmarks have one slightly higher than the other, while others have them swapped). Have you checked your CPU usage to see if it's maxing out? All the same, a new log would help us verify if there are encoder issues.
Well I didn't think it would be a problem because on the old OBS my recordings come out fine, it's the settings with the new OBS, ill put a log:
https://gist.github.com/27e76b6c381c3a88b588224efcb9b87e
 
That log is incomplete and does not show a full recording session. Please start a recording session and then fully stop recording before uploading the log. Please make sure to try to record for at least a few minutes.
 
From your log:
17:32:08.766: Output 'adv_file_output': Number of skipped frames due to encoding lag: 121 (15.8%)

It's still skipping frames, so your CPU cannot keep up with encoding at this level and Overwatch. You can try to reduce your output resolution, reduce your game settings, or switch to a hardware encoder (Quick Sync or VCE).


Also...
17:31:55.998: [x264 encoder: 'recording_h264'] custom settings: crf=15
You can remove this setting, as its redundant with your current settings.
 
From your log:


It's still skipping frames, so your CPU cannot keep up with encoding at this level and Overwatch. You can try to reduce your output resolution, reduce your game settings, or switch to a hardware encoder (Quick Sync or VCE).


Also...

You can remove this setting, as its redundant with your current settings.
That's strange, why does it work with the old OBS though? I guess I'll have to switch between the two. However this happens with relatively cheap games as well, like cheap indie games that don't require so much while I reduce the output resolution.

Also the only thing besides x264 i can use is the AMD video coding engine, except I don't know a guide to set it up and would it make a difference?
 
That's strange, why does it work with the old OBS though? I guess I'll have to switch between the two. However this happens with relatively cheap games as well, like cheap indie games that don't require so much while I reduce the output resolution.

Also the only thing besides x264 i can use is the AMD video coding engine, except I don't know a guide to set it up and would it make a difference?

As for why it works on one and not the other, I couldn't say for sure. Maybe your old settings have some other differences besides the CBR/CRF that you didn't notice? It's hard to tell from a single screenshot. If you have them configured exactly the same, but they perform differently, then that may be a bug, or it may just be a consequence of how OBS Studio is written. You'd have to rule out configuration differences and then file a bug report.

It's not just the game's intensiveness, it's also the encoding. Live encoding is not an inexpensive process, resource-wise, and you are trying to encode at 1080p@60fps. When you say you're reducing the output resolution, are you talking about the OBS Studio setting "Output (Scaled) Resolution", or are you talking about the game's resolution?

Yes, using VCE would most likely make a difference. It's a hardware encoder, so it would relieve the strain from your CPU. You've got a fairly new Radeon RX 480 there that should handle VCE pretty well. Please note, there is a difference between the Media Foundation AMD VCE and the AMD VCE plugin that I linked earlier.
 
As for why it works on one and not the other, I couldn't say for sure. Maybe your old settings have some other differences besides the CBR/CRF that you didn't notice? It's hard to tell from a single screenshot. If you have them configured exactly the same, but they perform differently, then that may be a bug, or it may just be a consequence of how OBS Studio is written. You'd have to rule out configuration differences and then file a bug report.

It's not just the game's intensiveness, it's also the encoding. Live encoding is not an inexpensive process, resource-wise, and you are trying to encode at 1080p@60fps. When you say you're reducing the output resolution, are you talking about the OBS Studio setting "Output (Scaled) Resolution", or are you talking about the game's resolution?

Yes, using VCE would most likely make a difference. It's a hardware encoder, so it would relieve the strain from your CPU. You've got a fairly new Radeon RX 480 there that should handle VCE pretty well. Please note, there is a difference between the Media Foundation AMD VCE and the AMD VCE plugin that I linked earlier.
Alright I'll take a look into the AMD VCE plugin and I'll post screenshots of the different settings in both versions of OBS

You still mot running as admin.
There's no need if I already said it doesn't work
 
I don't believe you.

Then believe me. I also tried on the same game, and running as administrator does not help when using Game Capture. If you don't believe me, try it for yourself. The game is free.

If it matters, the game seems to be built using Unity.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top