Question / Help Can I Stop Spacebar from Acting as a Hotkey?

Rory

New Member
My spacebar acts as a hotkey for whatever the last action I clicked on was, but it isn't set as a hotkey and I see no way to disable this. Any help is appreciated, I use spacebar to split during speedruns so this is very frustrating
 
This is defaults windows application behavior, not OBS. You can click on the preview or another part of the UI to keep it from happening.
 
This is defaults windows application behavior, not OBS. You can click on the preview or another part of the UI to keep it from happening.
Thanks, so click on the screen you mean? Also can I disable this through Windows? I did not have this issue with OBS Classic
 
No, you cannot disable it in windows. I did confirm it doesn't do the same thing in OBS classic, let me see if this is possible to tweak for studio.
 
Complete newbie here struggling with keyboard shortcuts. I've assigned "C" to <cut>, "M" to <fade> and "B" to <ftb>. problem is when i press c it also loads to the first Scene beginning with c and the same for any other key that matches the first letter of a scene. I've renamed all my scenes to start with an asteriek * so that's a workaround for now. I'd also like to use the spacebar for <cut> but that's not possible as it also does random stuff depending on what window you're in.
It seems to me that keyboard shortcuts are almost unusable in their present form in v25.0.8?
 
Shortcut keys and hotkeys are very different things. Hotkeys will trigger regardless of what window has focus.
 
Sorry I meant hotkeys.
If you assign a function to a hotkey eg "C" there seems also to be some sort of default function assigned to that key which also triggers when it's pressed, which is not shown in the Hotkey list. Similarly with the Spacebar, if you assign that in Settings to a function, it doesn't disable the default function ie it also triggers the last thing you clicked on. The Scenes thing can also be got around by clicking elsewhere so that nothing is highlighted in the scenes window. You can then press letter keys without loading a scene (beginning with that letter) into preview.
Interestingly it's possible to assign the same hotkey to more than one function. This could be seen as useful, but a warning to say that key had already been assigned would be a useful feature in future releases.
 
This seems fairly normal for any program that has a hotkey system. Can you provide an example of a program that suppresses a hotkey that shares a common operating system navigation function?
 
Other progammes I use for theatre tech stuff like SCS, vMix, Screenmonkey, Multiplay.
You seem to be able to press any key in those and it'll do nothing unless it's assigned to a function. The hotkeys in those apps seem to generally do exactly what you want. There is an issue in Screenmonkey that hotkeys always work ie if you're using spacebar as a "go" button and type a space when renaming something, it'll still trigger, but operationally, hotkeys work and only trigger the intended function.
Of course with those app hotkeys will not work if the window doesn't have the focus, which I'm quite used to. Maybe that's the issue here.
 
Just seen this thread -thehttps://obsproject.com/forum/threads/even-when-i-switch-to-other-programs-obs-hotkeys-steal-the-keyboard.109284/#:~:text=In%20OBS%2C%20it%20is%20not,ALT%2DF%7B1..

Maybe the answer is to use modifiers. I'd personally like to be able to switch windows and do other stuff while OBS carries on where I left it so an option to make hotkeys into keyboard shortcuts that only work when OBS is active would be a really useful feature. Just saying! Otherwise it's a great programme
 
Hello Gafferted and welcome to the OBS Forum. As a new member, you'll be learning all about the "HotKeys" and all of the bugs that come with them. You may even get a response from Joel Bethke, one of the programmers, who states that the Hotkey issues are not a high priority at this time. So, don't get your hopes up.

They will twist and squirm to try and get you to believe that Hotkeys and Shortcut Keys are different, THEY ARE ONE AND THE SAME!!!

Cool Edit Pro calls them Shortcut keys... OBS calls them Hotkeys.
Shortcut keys and Hotkeys are keys that are user programmable to execute a particular function. They are supposed to function in their own backyard, not the whole neighborhood. The programmers are just trying to hide their inadequacies. Don't be fooled.

I programmed my space bar as a transition and every time I hit it it stops OBS from recording. If I am live streaming and I want to start another "Scene" and rename it, I can't use the space bar as it will cause a transition. If I am in Firefox and I want to Google something, I can't use the space bar as it will cause a transition back in OBS.

I have opened Microsoft Word, Cool Edit Pro and Premiere Pro. I can use the spacebar in any of these programs without it affecting any other EXCEPT OBS; but according to Joel Bethke... It's not a high priority issue.

Maybe Fenrir could provide us with an example as to why this seems fairly normal for any program that has a Hotkey system.

They are probably going to censor me from telling the (no filth) truth about OBS, but I try and hit all the reviews with my comments.

If you look back at all of the comments here, you will read that OBS Classic acts differently from Studio and Fenrir is going to see if he can tweak it. How can he tweak it if it is "...fairly normal for any program that has a hotkey system."

If OBS worked the way it is supposed to, it would be a totally awesome program to be sure. I'm waiting for Ver. 100.


I'm surprised that all of the other entrenched hotkey dogmatics haven't awoken here and beat you up with their illogical views.

Check out all of the other subjects in the OBS forums. There's a message a minute. That speaks volumes.

Good Luck Gafferted!
 
This seems fairly normal for any program that has a hotkey system. Can you provide an example of a program that suppresses a hotkey that shares a common operating system navigation function?

Call me old fashioned but I've never come across a program that responds to key presses when it doesn't have focus. The ones I'm familiar with, SCS in particular, vMix or Qlab on the mac, even with focus do not respond to any keys at all, unless they're specifically assigned to a function. Without focus, they carry on as you left them whatever you do on the keyboard.
I don't know how the gaming community use OBS, perhaps it suits them like this?
As a theatre and events technician, looking into OBS as a way of streaming live performances with several cameras and a few slides and video clips, the hotkey system is a major problem as currently implemented. The almost random and unpredictable behaviour of the apparently non-documented, behind-the -scenes shortcuts that cannot be disabled makes OBS very tricky to use in a broadcasting environment, IMHO.

Having played a bit more, it seems the system hotkeys ARE disabled when you switch windows away from OBS so that's not quite so bad. With no hotkeys assigned and as long as you keep your hands off the keyboard (or disconnect it!) during a stream, you're reasonably safe from anything unexpected. However, as I type this in Chrome, my OBS (with a few letters assigned to transitions and scenes) is going crazy!

So, it might be safe to assign a few carefully chosen hotkeys with modifiers but that's hardly convenient. I'm used to using the spacebar as a "Go" button to action whatever I've set up in preview using the bottom row of letter keys. This is clearly not possible if I want the ability to switch windows and maybe look something up in a separate browser window for instance, while a video is playing.

It would be a much more useable app (for me at least) if it completely ignored keyboard input apart from functions that I have assigned. And only when OBS has focus.
Just saying!
 
OBS Studio has no feature to assign custom shortcuts that are active only as long as OBS Studio has focus. Some functions do have their hardcoded keyboard shortcuts, some do not. You cannot change this behavior, and you are not able to change hardcoded assignments. No add, no delete, no reassign.

In Settings->Hotkeys you define system-global hotkeys. System-global means regardless the active app in Windows. So if you define SPACE as hotkey here, whenever you press the spacebar, regardless the active app in windows, OBS will perform the corresponding action. The currently active app may also have an action connected to that key, and this action is performed as well.
Settings->Hotkeys are meant to define some CTRL/SHIFT/ALT/-key combinations not used by any other app to control OBS Studio operation while OBS Studio is in background, probably minimized.

Setting spacebar as hotkey in OBS Studio simply doesn't work out well. Since OBS in background will always listen to all hotkeys, you will perform the defined action multiple times if you enter text in any text input app.
CTRL-SHIFT-SPACE might work probably, but you never know how other apps currently active are reacting to this. More safe are CTRL/ALT/SHIFT combinations with the function keys F1..F12.
 
Thanks all.
Looking like I'll stick with Screenmonkey for projections and probably buy vMix for any serious streaming jobs that come my way.
OBS is clearly not aimed at the live event streaming market, and won't be a serious option unless the shortcut/hotkey problem is fixed. Shame because it's video capabilities really are very good. In all other respects it's a great piece of software, let down by a rather poorly thought out control interface.
 
OBS Studio is definitely aimed at the streaming market. It is its primary design goal. However, hotkey usage to micromanage OBS Studio is not included, and it is not feasible. The usual advanced streaming setup is to have 2 monitors. On one monitor you run OBS, the other monitor contains the stuff you stream. This way you have always the preview in direct view and you can directly control OBS with the mouse.

It may also be you didn't make use of every compositing tool OBS provides. Usually, you don't need much micromanagement during a stream. You prepare multiple scenes in advance. Different screen compositions. In the end, you only switch between your prepared scenes during stream. For this, the multiview is very convenient (Menu View->Multiview), and you can define up to 24 scenes to be included in the multiview in settings->General->Multiview.
If you need to customize scenes before you make them active, you use Studio mode.
All this is mouse clicking. There are so many features, you simply cannot assign hotkeys to all of it and remember all.

Instead of hotkeys, many streamers use stream decks. These are button panels with a bunch of keys, and you can assign each key a custom key combination/macro. From Windows point of view, this is simply a keyboard. Can be used to start apps, switch scenes, activate/deactivate certain sources to create some special effect in the current scene.
 
For live events, I will often be flicking between just two cameras and I'd really like to be able to use the the spacebar to do that reliably, with no possibility of any unexpected behaviour. Having briefly tried it on a mac, it seems that it may in fact be possible? The spacebar doesn't appear to do anything unless specifically assigned as a hotkey. Fingers crossed!
 
Another newbie here, a retired UI designer, software developer and product manager. Also an experienced TV Director.

In my experience, apps should very seldom -- if ever -- define system-global keys in a multi-tasking environment, since an app has no idea what else the user might be doing while that app is running in the background (that is, when the app does not have focus). Even making hotkeys app-global must be done with care. For example, the app should ignore hotkeys when a text-input field has focus to avoid triggering the function assigned to the hotkey when that key is pressed during text entry.

As a newbie, I naively defined individual letters to my scenes, lower thirds and quick transitions. When I returned to OBS in the midst of typing this post I discovered several lower thirds on the screen, and Studio had selected a different scene and cut between program and preview.

Users might expect that the purpose of hotkeys is to expedite activation and deactivation of scenes, sources, transitions, etc. Single key-presses meet this need; the requirement to press some combination of Ctrl/Shift/Alt + another key does not.
 
Perdón por hacer mi pregunta aquí ... pero está relacionada con las teclas de acceso rápido. He configurado algunos atajos para activar / desactivar el micrófono y para cambiar a la escena 1, escena 2 y escena 3. Todo funciona si estás en primer plano o incluso si estás en el área de notificaciones. pero deja de funcionar cuando tengo mi videojuego en pantalla completa. alguien me ayude a arreglar esto?
 
Run OBS as administrator. In the future, you can just make a new thread for an issue unrelated to an existing thread.
 
Back
Top