Question / Help very grainy video at 1080p

when recording and streaming. first time i actually tried recording with obs and was doing it at 1920x1080. only example i have is the vid i just uploaded
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=saSkXfZ9F_E

my specs
intel i7 4790
12gb ram
gtx 960 ssc

internet speed is 100 down and 10 up

heres my logfile as well please help and thanks

https://gist.github.com/6d22b12e6ff4cc995e36

i notice its only when there is movement going on in the game. its not the game cause it does this with every game.
 
srry i should have corrected myself. i record at 1080p but stream at 1536x864
you dont record at 1080 thats just what your source video is and has nothing to do with the output to your stream.

you can do one of two things, increase your bitrate to maybe 3200 bitrate OR lower your downscale to 720p. Either solution will give you more bitrate per pixel which is where your quality comes from.

I would advise just dropping the downscale because your are duplicating frames which means with all you have in your scene, your CPU cant quite keep up
 
Statistically meaningless:
13:39:15: Total frames encoded: 324, total frames duplicated: 43 (13.27%)
Statistically valid:
14:15:01: Total frames encoded: 62812, total frames duplicated: 151 (0.24%)

So duplicated frames are fine. But still, I agree that you should increase your downscale another notch. It'll look better for exactly the reason dping says, more bits dedicated to each pixel. And this way is more bandwidth-friendly to your viewers.

On the other hand, if you're not concerned about your viewers and you want the best local recording, then I'd stay with the current resolution and just increase the bitrate to Twitch's maximum: 3500.

And an even better solution would be to run OBS twice, once for the recording to disk and again for the stream. Or to run the multiplatform version. The objective being to record at full resolution and high bitrate, and to stream at a lower resolution and internet-friendly bitrate. But running OBS twice is a far more complicated solution.
 
Last edited:
Nothing. See if its less grainy. If still grainy, post a new log file. And a link to the VOD.

well what im saying is its all been grainy. and yes it would be more grainy if u brought it down even more looking on the same screen u were watching it before. more popular streamers dont have this problem because they are doing something that im not so if its at 720 what should bitrate be and ill do a test
 
well what im saying is its all been grainy. and yes it would be more grainy if u brought it down even more looking on the same screen u were watching it before. more popular streamers dont have this problem because they are doing something that im not so if its at 720 what should bitrate be and ill do a test
There are a few issues with what you are saying.
more popular streamers have either:
1. Best systems where they drop the CPU preset and/or use higher bitrates because they can transcode being partnered or above a certain amount of viewers
2. use 2PC setups with expensive capture cards in combination with above


something to note that arma3 and H1Z1 and other games that have grass to encode often take more encoding time to look good. this is because the textures and complex entities in game cant be encoded as easily.

More often than not you have to balance the bitrate with either lower fps or lower resolution to hit the same quality. This is game dependent. meaning if its a FPS, has a lot of grass, is a very fast paced game, it will look better with higher bitrates, lower resolution. If its a static screen like a card game or a top down like LoL it is easier to encode and can look better at higher resolutions with your same bitrate. This is why some LoL streamers can do 1080@30 3500 bitrate yet you'll never see someone do this in first person games.

I would get into presets but until you post a new log like boildown asked, we don't know how your CPU is dealing with 720@30.
 
Um, your VOD looks fine. You're being overly critical. Unless you spend $5000 on dedicated streaming gear, you're not going to make it look substantially better than what your VOD shows.
 
Um, your VOD looks fine. You're being overly critical. Unless you spend $5000 on dedicated streaming gear, you're not going to make it look substantially better than what your VOD shows.

ok good to know. one question i have is i know that some streamers use 2 pcs and a capture card but if u have a capture card whats the point of using a 2nd pc?
 
and just to make it look alittle better i brought it up to 1536x864 with 3000 bitrate should i change bitrate? im just trying to make it look alittle better if i should change it back just let me know
 
The capture card captures the video from the gaming machine. It means that the streaming machine (with the capture card) only has to focus on encoding, and doesn't have to bear the load of gaming at the same time.

A capture card will do exactly nothing for you in a 1 PC setup; it won't offload anything from the CPU or GPU, and is actually LESS efficient than just Game Capturing the source.

No. Stop it. Downscale back to 720p.
You'll have a WORSE bits-per-pixel density at 864p, and it will only make the stream look bad.
 
The capture card captures the video from the gaming machine. It means that the streaming machine (with the capture card) only has to focus on encoding, and doesn't have to bear the load of gaming at the same time.

A capture card will do exactly nothing for you in a 1 PC setup; it won't offload anything from the CPU or GPU, and is actually LESS efficient than just Game Capturing the source.

No. Stop it. Downscale back to 720p.
You'll have a WORSE bits-per-pixel density at 864p, and it will only make the stream look bad.

oh ok good to know and alright srry i put it back to 720p keep bitrate at 3000? i also turned cbr off because i dont really know what it is. later on down the road i might try to stream just at 1080 but thats probably too much on my pc
 
oh ok good to know and alright srry i put it back to 720p keep bitrate at 3000? i also turned cbr off because i dont really know what it is. later on down the road i might try to stream just at 1080 but thats probably too much on my pc
If you dont know what it is, dont touch it. you need CBR and CBR padding to stream properly. without it the bitrate will fluctuate and cause viewers to buffer.

as for usings 720p30 3000 vs 864p. 720p will look slightly less sharp but the whole picutre will look less pixellated especially during movement. 864p will look sharper but more grainy during movement.
 
If you dont know what it is, dont touch it. you need CBR and CBR padding to stream properly. without it the bitrate will fluctuate and cause viewers to buffer.

as for usings 720p30 3000 vs 864p. 720p will look slightly less sharp but the whole picutre will look less pixellated especially during movement. 864p will look sharper but more grainy during movement.

ok i put cbr padding on. and i never knew it would be like that thats so weird i thought since higher resolution it would look better. ill keep the 720p 30 fps 3000 bitrate. and if it was on 1080 then it would look the best then? i was wrong about how obs works haha
 
ok i put cbr padding on. and i never knew it would be like that thats so weird i thought since higher resolution it would look better. ill keep the 720p 30 fps 3000 bitrate. and if it was on 1080 then it would look the best then? i was wrong about how obs works haha
No, you are playing arma 3, a first person shooter with a lot of movement and high quality textures like grass that will make it look even more "grainy" aka pixellated at 1080p. leave it at 720p and post a new log file with those settings.
 
Think of bitrate like paint. Your resolution (and framerate) is the size of a wall you're trying to paint. If you have a HUGE wall and only a little paint bucket, it's going to look like crap.
If you have a smaller wall, the same amount of paint will go on thicker and look better. Of course there's a point where more paint won't really help much, but that takes a lot.
 
Think of bitrate like paint. Your resolution (and framerate) is the size of a wall you're trying to paint. If you have a HUGE wall and only a little paint bucket, it's going to look like crap.
If you have a smaller wall, the same amount of paint will go on thicker and look better. Of course there's a point where more paint won't really help much, but that takes a lot.

ah ok makes sense
 
Back
Top