Question / Help Which cpu for a dedicated stream pc?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 59113
  • Start date Start date
D

Deleted member 59113

Just a quick run down of what the set up would be.
Gaming PC:
12gb Ram
Gtx 770
I5-2500k

Streaming pc:
Avermedia Live Gamer HD Capture card
4gb ram
No graphics card
I5-2500s
z68ap-ds3 Motherboard

I am going to upgrade the CPU in the streaming pc as the gaming pc maxes out all the games I play at present no problem,
the question is which cpu should I go for on a budget of about £100? (2nd hand included)
I'm currently looking at - I7-2600k, I5-3570k or a Xeon E3-1230 (significantly cheaper)
at the moment I am swaying toward the xeon but not sure which would work best in a dedicated stream pc.

Thoughts on those 3, or alternatives?
 
The 2600's hyperthreading would be nice but the iGPU would be pretty terrible and I'm not sure if QSV would even be supported. I don't think the Xeon E3-1230 even has an iGPU so that would require an additional investment in some type of graphics hardware. Something like a 3770 would be more ideal.
 
The 2600's hyperthreading would be nice but the iGPU would be pretty terrible and I'm not sure if QSV would even be supported. I don't think the Xeon E3-1230 even has an iGPU so that would require an additional investment in some type of graphics hardware. Something like a 3770 would be more ideal.

I'll be using x264 anyway, not abig fan of quick sync, I have an AMD 7870 knocking around somewhere if need be for the streaming pc but I'd prefer to stick to quality and go with x264.
The game I want to stream was terrible on quick sync last time I tested, pixelation made it look horrible even at high bitrates.

I'll check out your suggestion, if quick sync isnt needed would any of those be good?
 
Maybe I am overlooking this, until now my set up was gaming pc > streaming pc via rtmp, now I have a capture card I am dedicating everything to the streaming pc, before I was using Nvenc to send the info across via Lan, now I am having a solely dedicated streaming pc, do I need a graphics card to help do some of the other work like compositing etc?
 
Either get the i7 2600k/2700k or the Xeon e3-1230 as a dedicated CPU.

If I had my System already upgraded I would be able to sell you my i7 2700k for really cheap, but its currently still running in my System :(

I think most h77 Boards support QSV and Sandy Bridge CPUs while the p67 Chipsets mostly dont support it.
 
Last edited:
Either get the i7 2600k/2700k or the Xeon e3-1230 as a dedicated CPU.

If I had my System already upgraded I would be able to sell you my i7 2700k for really cheap, but its currently still running in my System :(

I think most h77 Boards support QSV and Sandy Bridge CPUs while the p67 Chipsets mostly dont support it.

Well I will still have an i5-2500k in the gaming pc so feel free to message me in the future when you upgrade!
What are your stream settings? Quality looks great!
 
Oh, and what do you mean by "dedicated cpu" ? I am assuming you mean dedicated in a general sense that it does not have a IGPU therefore I will need a graphics card to do that side of the work on the streaming pc?
As I said I do have a 7870 lying around (and a 7850 somewhere) that I can chuck in to the pc, so providing that is enough, it will be much cheaper for me to get the xeon e3-1230 it seems, which looks pretty much like a decent I7 in terms of performance from a streaming perspective, but the I7 does have the benefits of the IGPU and overclocking for future if needed.

I'm now really torn between the 2600k/2700k (which look pretty much identical so whichever I can pick up cheaper) and the Xeon.
Will I realistically need quick sync in a dedicated streaming pc with either 2600/700k or xeon e3-1230?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Also whats the deal with Version numbers on xeons? Seen the e3-1230/v2/v3?

EDIT - Seems to be slightly higher clock speeds/specs etc, not much difference between them, seems the xeon i've seen is just the basic.
 
With dedicated I meant the whole System dedicated to encoding.

QSV is not necessary its only about the support for the internal GPU in those Core i's else you would have to throw in a GPU.

The Numbers at the end of the Xeons are the identification of the generation.

Xeons without a v identification are usually Sandy Bridge based, v2 Ivy Bride v3 Haswell v4 Broadwell and soon probably the v5 for Skylake.

That means another Chipset + Socket which is important when it comes to Mainboards and also the compatibility since Intel was kinda against the use of Xeons for normal Desktop CPUs but the Price/Performance was just insane since the 4C/8T E3 1240v2 was only 250€ while the 3770 came at over 300 and was essentially the same.


My OBS Settings Im not sure right now, I think I stream 720p48 with Veryfast Preset and 2500ish Bitrate.
 
With dedicated I meant the whole System dedicated to encoding.

QSV is not necessary its only about the support for the internal GPU in those Core i's else you would have to throw in a GPU.

The Numbers at the end of the Xeons are the identification of the generation.

Xeons without a v identification are usually Sandy Bridge based, v2 Ivy Bride v3 Haswell v4 Broadwell and soon probably the v5 for Skylake.

That means another Chipset + Socket which is important when it comes to Mainboards and also the compatibility since Intel was kinda against the use of Xeons for normal Desktop CPUs but the Price/Performance was just insane since the 4C/8T E3 1240v2 was only 250€ while the 3770 came at over 300 and was essentially the same.


My OBS Settings Im not sure right now, I think I stream 720p48 with Veryfast Preset and 2500ish Bitrate.


Ok well maybe the Xeon could be hassle? or would the Xeon e3-1230 that I am looking at work with my 1150 socket? according to http://www.cpu-world.com/Sockets/Socket_1150_LGA1150_H3.html It would be okay? Just don't want any later issues, I can easily chuck in a graphics card with the Xeon if it's going to be worth it, if not I will just go for the I7-2600/700k which I can get for slightly more.
 
And the xeon has no version number which suggests it's the Sandy and will work with my mobo.
The listing just says Intel Xeon Processor CPU E3-1230 SR00H 3.20GHz
 
Yep that should be the norm
When do you plan to upgrade your set up? as I said I will still have an i5 in my gaming pc so could upgrade that if you wanted to sell whenever is convenient for you!
 
When do you plan to upgrade your set up? as I said I will still have an i5 in my gaming pc so could upgrade that if you wanted to sell whenever is convenient for you!

I actually wanted to hop on the RyZen train but IMHO its not exactly what I was looking for since I play CPU intensive games and those are the ones that literally perform the same or even worse compared to my i7 though for just encoding they are fine ... so as soon as Skylake-X hits the market I will be gone and thats still a couple of month ahead.
 
Back
Top