RTX 5090 – Stuttering in recordings despite smooth gameplay

NpexX

New Member
Hello everyone,


I have a reproducible recording/capture issue with my RTX 5090.


System:


  • RTX 5090
  • Ryzen 9 9950X3D
  • ASUS ProArt X870E
  • 96 GB DDR5-6000
  • Windows 11 Pro

The actual gameplay is smooth, but the recorded video shows noticeable frame-pacing issues, micro-stutters and irregular motion.


The issue is not limited to OBS. It occurs with:


  • OBS Studio
  • NVIDIA App / ShadowPlay
  • Meld Studio
  • Windows Game DVR / Game Bar

I have already tested different drivers, recording settings, monitor configurations and capture methods.


Most importantly, my retailer/service provider was able to reproduce the same issue on a completely different system using a Ryzen 9 9950X3D, ROG Strix B850 and a different Zotac RTX 5090.


This makes me suspect a possible RTX 50-series / Blackwell driver or capture pipeline issue.


Has anyone experienced the same behavior with an RTX 5090?
Has anyone compared an RTX 5090 vs. RTX 4090 on the same system?


I can provide video examples if needed.
 
This issue seems to affect lately more and more people and nothing seems to be done to solve the actual problems. People on this forum will likely say that your settings suck or the classic "my OBS works fine".
I'll try to follow along this thread as well because I am having the same issues with my build and also a previous build, both really strong, where there should be no issues at all.
 
In my opinion, it can't be related to OBS, since I experience the same problem with ShadowPlay, Meld Studio, and Game Bar as well, even with the default settings.
 
The fact the same issue appears with the Nvidia App recordings too is extremely odd.

That said, there's a number of potentially benign reasonable explanations. Both a log from OBS (to understand your setup/config) and perhaps an example video with contextual explanation from you would help.

An example of a benign issue: a game running at around 90fps will never have good pacing or motion when recorded at 60fps, and can look choppy. This is why more context & info from you might be helpful.
 
So it turns out the problem intensifies if the game is running at 60 fps, problem doesn't go away after setting the refresh rate to 60hz. also the problem appears to not happen through the Nvidia app
Flashing warning for the videos
 
The fact the same issue appears with the Nvidia App recordings too is extremely odd.

That said, there's a number of potentially benign reasonable explanations. Both a log from OBS (to understand your setup/config) and perhaps an example video with contextual explanation from you would help.

An example of a benign issue: a game running at around 90fps will never have good pacing or motion when recorded at 60fps, and can look choppy. This is why more context & info from you might be helpful.
Thanks for the detailed response. I agree that the fact that the same behavior also occurs with NVIDIA App/ShadowPlay recordings is particularly strange.

Unfortunately, my PC is currently with the retailer/service provider, so I don't have access to it at the moment and therefore can't provide a fresh OBS log right now.

I have checked and analyzed OBS logs extensively in the past, though, and there was never anything indicating an error or an obvious performance/encoding problem. As far as the logs were concerned, everything looked normal.

I'll leave a link to my YouTube channel below, where you can see examples of the issue:


To describe the problem more precisely: the recording initially looks completely normal. After a random amount of time, a noticeable jitter/shaking starts to appear in the OBS preview. The timing is not consistent — sometimes it happens relatively quickly, sometimes much later. The important part is that this is not just an OBS preview issue: the same jitter/motion irregularity is also present in the resulting recording.

The actual game itself remains smooth while playing. The problem is therefore mainly visible in the capture/recording output.

Regarding your 90 FPS → 60 FPS example: I understand what you mean, but in my case I am specifically recording at 4K 60 FPS, and the entire setup is configured around 60 FPS. The monitors, in-game FPS limit, OBS recording settings, etc. are all configured accordingly. I have also tested different refresh rates and configurations, including 60 Hz, to rule out a simple frame-rate/frame-pacing mismatch.

The issue has also been reproduced by my retailer on a completely different system using another RTX 5090, which is one of the reasons I'm wondering whether this could be related to the RTX 50-series/Blackwell capture pipeline rather than my individual hardware.

The videos on my channel should give you a much better idea of what I mean by the jitter, since it is quite difficult to describe accurately in text.
 
Thanks for the detailed response. I agree that the fact that the same behavior also occurs with NVIDIA App/ShadowPlay recordings is particularly strange.

Unfortunately, my PC is currently with the retailer/service provider, so I don't have access to it at the moment and therefore can't provide a fresh OBS log right now.

I have checked and analyzed OBS logs extensively in the past, though, and there was never anything indicating an error or an obvious performance/encoding problem. As far as the logs were concerned, everything looked normal.

I'll leave a link to my YouTube channel below, where you can see examples of the issue:


To describe the problem more precisely: the recording initially looks completely normal. After a random amount of time, a noticeable jitter/shaking starts to appear in the OBS preview. The timing is not consistent — sometimes it happens relatively quickly, sometimes much later. The important part is that this is not just an OBS preview issue: the same jitter/motion irregularity is also present in the resulting recording.

The actual game itself remains smooth while playing. The problem is therefore mainly visible in the capture/recording output.

Regarding your 90 FPS → 60 FPS example: I understand what you mean, but in my case I am specifically recording at 4K 60 FPS, and the entire setup is configured around 60 FPS. The monitors, in-game FPS limit, OBS recording settings, etc. are all configured accordingly. I have also tested different refresh rates and configurations, including 60 Hz, to rule out a simple frame-rate/frame-pacing mismatch.

The issue has also been reproduced by my retailer on a completely different system using another RTX 5090, which is one of the reasons I'm wondering whether this could be related to the RTX 50-series/Blackwell capture pipeline rather than my individual hardware.

The videos on my channel should give you a much better idea of what I mean by the jitter, since it is quite difficult to describe accurately in text.
Please keep us posted when/if you have any info on possible solutions.
 
Hi everyone,

I'm experiencing almost exactly the same problems with a very similar system.

My hardware:

  • AMD Ryzen 9 9950X3D
  • ASUS TUF Gaming RTX 5090 OC
  • 64 GB DDR5-6000 CL30
  • ASRock X870E Taichi Creator
  • Windows 11
I'm recording gameplay in 4K60 using OBS and NVIDIA NVENC.

The issue:

Games usually run smoothly with stable FPS, but the recorded videos randomly suffer from severe stuttering, jittering and uneven frame pacing. It almost looks like V-Sync suddenly stops working.

Sometimes the recording is smooth from beginning to end. Other times the stuttering starts immediately, after a few minutes, or comes and goes throughout the recording. It can last anywhere from a few seconds to several minutes.

OBS statistics show almost no dropped frames. In one severely affected recording, I had only 5 missed frames due to rendering lag and 0 skipped frames due to encoding lag.

What I've tried:

  • Multiple NVIDIA drivers, including hotfix 621.12 and clean installations using DDU
  • Different OBS versions, including 33.0.1
  • NVENC AV1, H.264 and HEVC
  • Game Capture and Display Capture
  • CBR and CQP
  • Internal NVMe SSD and external storage
  • HAGS enabled and disabled
  • Different FPS limits and V-Sync settings
  • Windows Clean Boot
  • Disabling MPO
  • MKV with automatic MP4 remuxing
Unfortunately, nothing has provided a reliable solution.

For example, I recently recorded 20 minutes of The Last of Us Part II almost perfectly. Shortly afterwards, Call of Duty and Battlefield recordings suffered from severe stuttering again, without changing any settings.

The problem is completely unpredictable, even after restarting Windows.

Has anyone found a reliable solution, or could an OBS developer help investigate this issue? I'm also interested in whether RTSS frame limiting has helped.

Thanks!
 
@Tommes80

 
@Tommes80

1. The Hardware-accelerated GPU scheduling ("HAGS") feature in Windows is currently known to cause performance and capture issues with OBS, games and overlay tools. Since you are having issues with performance, we recommend disabling it via this screen or these instructions as a troubleshooting step. Be sure to restart your PC after disabling it.
2. Your GPU is maxed out and OBS can't render scenes (0.1%) and encode frames (0.1%) fast enough. Running a game without vertical sync or a frame rate limiter will frequently cause performance issues with OBS because your GPU will be maxed out. OBS requires a little GPU to render your scene.

Enable Vsync or set a reasonable frame rate limit (120, 60, 30) that your GPU can handle without hitting 100% usage.

If that's not enough you may also need to turn down some of the video quality options in the game. If you are experiencing issues in general while using OBS, your GPU may be overloaded for the settings you are trying to use.

Please check our guide for ideas why this may be happening, and steps you can take to correct it: GPU Overload Issues. In OBS go to Settings > Recording > Set Multipass Mode to Single Pass and disable Adaptive Quantization. Both of those use additional GPU.

If still having issues, provide a new log.
 
@qhobbes

Thanks for your reply!

The 99% GPU usage was probably from the beginning of the OBS session, when V-Sync and the 60 FPS limiter were temporarily disabled. Both were enabled again before the actual recording.

The stuttering happens regardless of GPU usage, even when the GPU has plenty of headroom.

I've already tested disabling HAGS (which made things significantly worse), different FPS limiters, V-Sync settings, and switching from two-pass to single-pass encoding.

The only suggested setting I haven't tested yet is disabling Adaptive Quantization. I'll give that a try.

Unfortunately, the recordings still suffer from periodic stuttering and duplicated frames, even though gameplay itself is perfectly smooth.
 
This took me a lot of research, but....NVIDIA sometimes will forget about your other CPU needs to the OS and hardware. We only look at the OBS logs here, but we should also look at the NVIDIA settings.

Cause of Stutter:

By default, NVIDIA set the Max Pre-rendered Frames to 2. Low Latency and Ultra Low Latency will use a value of 1. What these settings are doing is telling the CPU to keep 1 or 2 frames and give it to the GPU as fast as it can; CPU-GPU is too tight. This is excellent for something like small PI devices, AI, or robotics. But DirectX is different. If the CPU cannot keep up with the GPU for every 1 frame (Reflex or Ultra Low Latency), then the GPU will become idle and start sleeping or decrease its operation, which can cause stuttering, fps drops, and a lot of problems, because we are asking the CPU to work faster than the speed of light.

Solution:

In my research, I found that a setting of Max Pre-Rendered Frames of 4 (Intel recommends 3 when using Game Mode), will smooth out the CPU-GPU work, even with Frame Generation. The GPU can use what it wants, but this will decouple the tight CPU-GPU and allow the CPU to also serve its other tasks to the operating system and devices. The CPU can hold 4 frames and will have more than enough time to hand the GPU whatever it needs asynchronously. The GPU will also be able to reuse old and new frames as it should as fast as it can, reducing stutter to near zero. The idea that "latency is higher" is not relevant if you have a RTX GPU and a modern NVMe SSD. This also helps OBS and its recordings / streaming because the CPU-GPU is not extremely tight.
 
Is it same issue as in this post here? The sync drift line issue?

For me, the sync drift line reaching top or bottom of screen causes jitter and preventing that is necessary. Though it's a workaround rather than a real solution. But apart from that, recording at solid 60 fps in game on ~60.000020 Hz single monitor with vsync and no other limiters works well for me, with no jitter or hitching in 2+ hour recordings.

I also noticed (on my pc anyway) seeking through a video can cause what looks like frame pacing issues, but pausing it and then playing seems to fix that.
 
Thanks to both of you for your suggestions!

Regarding the NVIDIA settings: Low Latency Mode was previously set to Ultra, but I changed it to Off during troubleshooting. Unfortunately, I can't remember which NVIDIA driver was installed when Ultra was active.

As far as I know, the old "Maximum Pre-Rendered Frames" setting is no longer available in the current NVIDIA Control Panel, so I cannot directly set it to 4 as suggested.

Regarding the synchronization issue: I've already tested both 60 Hz / 60 FPS and 59.94 Hz / 59.94 FPS, including V-Sync and different frame limiters. Unfortunately, neither configuration eliminated the problem.

The strange thing is that gameplay itself can remain perfectly smooth at 60 FPS, while the OBS recording suddenly shows duplicated frames and noticeable stuttering for several seconds, sometimes up to a minute. After that, the recording becomes smooth again until the next occurrence.

OBS usually reports almost no rendering or encoding lag, which makes this particularly difficult to diagnose.

I've also tested disabling HAGS, which made things significantly worse, and switching from two-pass to single-pass encoding without solving the issue.

Thanks again for taking the time to investigate this. I really appreciate any further suggestions!
 
@Tommes80 for PCs it is important to follow exact actions and to have exact numbers. Of course, you may do it in a "similar" way, but then the result may not be the same. Yeah, many people, don't understands that the algorithms are strict for most of the simple machines (not AI powered), and you need to follow exact instructions to get the same result. If you think that the mentioned "60.000020 Hz" in previous post is just mistake or allegory, exaggeration, then, nope - it is exact number. Out of the box, the mismatch can be +0.24Hz (from my own experience) for the display device, and it fluctuates with time. Try to read the mentioned thread in full. If you don't wish to, there are other workarounds - OBS code modifications, the info can be found in the related threads: https://obsproject.com/forum/thread...me-frame-pacing-is-even-per-capframex.196556/ some users says that it works OK.

Edit: typos.
 
Last edited:
At 60.001 Hz or 59.95 Hz for example the jitter would be frequent on my PC.

Here's a screen cap from the video in the thread I linked, the tear line reaching top or bottom is when the jitter happens. But for me, there's also a zone near within top third of screen that can trigger a jitter if tear line moves through it.

refresh rate stutter prediction.png
 
Thanks to both of you for your suggestions!

Regarding the NVIDIA settings: Low Latency Mode was previously set to Ultra, but I changed it to Off during troubleshooting. Unfortunately, I can't remember which NVIDIA driver was installed when Ultra was active.

As far as I know, the old "Maximum Pre-Rendered Frames" setting is no longer available in the current NVIDIA Control Panel, so I cannot directly set it to 4 as suggested.

Regarding the synchronization issue: I've already tested both 60 Hz / 60 FPS and 59.94 Hz / 59.94 FPS, including V-Sync and different frame limiters. Unfortunately, neither configuration eliminated the problem.

The strange thing is that gameplay itself can remain perfectly smooth at 60 FPS, while the OBS recording suddenly shows duplicated frames and noticeable stuttering for several seconds, sometimes up to a minute. After that, the recording becomes smooth again until the next occurrence.

OBS usually reports almost no rendering or encoding lag, which makes this particularly difficult to diagnose.

I've also tested disabling HAGS, which made things significantly worse, and switching from two-pass to single-pass encoding without solving the issue.

Thanks again for taking the time to investigate this. I really appreciate any further suggestions!
Yeah, the problem is.....Maximum Pre-Rendered Frames is replaced by Ultra Low Latency. Only the NVIDIA Profile Inspector tool can set it now. It's still a bit intriguing that working groups believe that the CPU can really keep up with these powerful GPUs. The moment that the GPU is finished, it's waiting on the CPU. Arcade machines didn't have this problem because there is nothing to disturb the CPU.
 
Back
Top