RTX 5090 – Stuttering in recordings despite smooth gameplay

My $0.50 (complete info, might be repeating what others have said)
1) OBS requires some GPU resources
2) captured frame uniqueness is not guaranteed for Game Capture
3) OBS requires HAGS off to avoid frame pacing issues reliably
4) OBS should be launched with admin privileges to apply automatic fixes against Game Mode
5) there's "SLI/CF capture mode" checkbox for game capture which reduces performance but may work more reliably
6) there's "limit capture framerate" checkbox which can be useful
7) you can try recording desktop instead of game capture too

For me, "limit capture framerate", disabling HAGS and running with admin privileges gives me almost perfect recording in Superposition 8K with Radeon 7900XTX and lots of stutter otherwise.
 
I should ask my AI friend what is really happening. I used CoPilot to tune Windows 11 over the last few weeks and I had really great results (with validation of course). I see the log.
 
What I see is....the game is moving between queue states and OBS is trying to capture them again. Then it's freed, then its captured again, so it might be creating hitches:

capture freed
capture successful

There are multiple logs with:
Remembering D3D12 queue from first direct submit after present.

Your CPU and everything looks nice. AV1 is not even struggling, so that cannot be an issue.

What is sticking out are these Direct3D 12 queue logs. Something about DirectX 12's swap chain....it needs to present (display to the screen) and then grab the next frame from the CPU. But OBS needs to wait until the GPU is finished, then it captures again. I almost had an eye on HAGS, but not yet. I think it's DirectX 12's programming and the programmer needs to look at the logs....but is it possible to make DirectX 11 adaptative? I don't know. Maybe OBS need to rest on one multiplane. Its definitely something about VSync that is plaguing the community with these stutters.

But there are multiple programmers, Microsoft, AMD, etc.... So some other things to look at.

GameDVR is on. It lives in the presentation path. Try turning this off.

Metro Exodus is doing some unusual things on the overlays. Maybe this is why NVIDIA recommended disabling the Multiplane Overlay. That is a valid clue that I rarely talked about.....video games causing fullscreen states to change and OBS has to recapture. It happens very fast or it's transparent to our eyes, but OBS is having a difficult time with different multiplanes or fullscreen states.

This is another reason why I stopped selecting VRR Fullscreen and Windowed and select Fullscreen only.

Another part of the log that is likely:

render_video max=87 ms
gs_flush max=87 ms

This is showing the stalls between CPU GPU, so something is going on here. Whatever is happening, OBS is switching presentation modes.

Do you have any hybrid graphics enabled? NVIDIA Optimus might cause OBS to switch presentation modes. Hybrid graphics is nice, but both GPUs might fight over different presentation modes, memory strategies, etc.

Try disabling that AMD Radeon Graphics and record again.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top